Twenty-year-old center Sam Steel scored the first goal of his NHL life and 23-year-old winger Kiefer Sherwood (who like Kariya is half-Japanese) potted the second of his career, but they were all for naught in a 4-2 defeat to the visiting Buffalo Sabres.
Buffalo wiped out an early two-goal Ducks advantage and took its first lead four minutes into the third on a Rasmus Ristolainen slap shot on the power play, one of four on the night for the Sabres.
"We took three penalties in a row, and that changed the momentum of the game," said Ducks captain Ryan Getzlaf, who played his second straight game after returning from injury (both losses). "They got going a little bit on the power play and got after us. That's probably the turning point."
Despite the early lead, the Ducks struggled for much of the evening and kept it close on the back of goalie Ryan Miller, who had 41 saves against his former team. Miller went to the bench with little more than a minute left, and the Ducks had a few chances to tie it, but they were denied by Buffalo goalie Carter Hutton. A scramble in the Buffalo crease nearly produced the tying goal, but the dagger came when the Sabres' Patrik Berglund filled the empty Anaheim net with 16.1 seconds left.
The pregame festivities featured a retrospective of Kariya's prolific career, as well as speeches from Ducks owner Henry Samueli, former teammates Teemu Selanne and Steve Rucchin, former Ducks captain Scott Niedermayer, longtime Ducks Senior Vice President of Hockey Operations David McNab and Kariya himself.
"Over the years, many of the games, the wins and loses have faded from my mind," Kariya said. "Thank you for making tonight the most memorable night of my life."
That speech was followed by Kariya's banner being raised to the rafters alongside Selanne's number 8, while Kariya and partner Valerie Dawson watched front and center.