The following day, Makar and UMass played in the NCAA championship game, losing 3-0 to the University of Minnesota Duluth.
After the game, Makar signed a three-year, entry-level contract with the Avalanche.
He was scheduled to fly to Denver from Buffalo on Sunday with a connecting flight in Newark, N.J., but his parents wound up driving him to Toronto, from where he took a direct flight after a 90-minute wait in customs. He landed in Denver at 8 p.m. ET and took part in the morning skate Monday.
Finally, at 10:17 p.m., he stepped onto the Pepsi Center ice for his first NHL shift, wearing No. 8.
"It was pretty weird, special," Makar said. "It's a cool moment. You've been working your whole life for this. It was pretty exciting. The nerves kind of went away after the first period, but it was fun."
Thirty minutes later, with the Avalanche leading 2-0, Makar received a drop pass from Nathan MacKinnon and skated down the right slot before scoring five-hole on Flames goalie Mike Smith.
"[MacKinnon] made a really good drop pass there and honestly, I just tried to get it inside the (defense) and try to slip one on net and hope for the rebound," Makar said. "Fortunately, it went in."