Despite playing without Kyle Okposo, who missed the game with an illness, and Sam Reinhart, who dressed but did not play after violating a team policy (more on that below), the Sabres were able to outshoot the Blue Jackets 42-29. The only time they were able to beat Bobrovsky was on a one-time shot from Evan Rodrigues on a power play in the second period.
The Blue Jackets, meanwhile, got all of their offense during a three-minute stretch in which they controlled the pace of play late in the first period. Kyle Quincey opened the scoring with 5:13 left in the period, intercepting a clearing attempt at the blue line and beating Nilsson with a shot through traffic. Cam Atkinson extended the Columbus lead to 2-0 when he lifted a puck over Nilsson's shoulder 2:59 later.
Rodrigues' goal cut that lead in half with 9:07 still left to play in the second, but every attempt to tie the game from that point on was either stifled by Bobrovsky or by a play in front of the net. There were extended zone times, a 2-on-1 rush between Evander Kane and Jack Eichel, a near breakaway for Ryan O'Reilly - but none of it led to goals.
Both Dan Bylsma and Ryan O'Reilly suggested that, while Bobrovsky did have a good night, the Sabres could have done more at the net-front to impair his vision and make life hard for the Columbus goalie.
"Towards the end there I thought we were dominating, we hemmed them in a bunch of times," O'Reilly said. "It's just, you've got to find a way. When the passes aren't perfect and you find a way to get it into the O-zone, the net presence, it's big. We got it back to the point a lot and guys were moving, it's just competing in front of the net and they did a good job of boxing us out."
Columbus earned its final goal when Brandon Saad scored into an empty net with 1:05 remaining.
The Sabres had entered the night with wins in four of their last five games, including the last two. They accomplished, for the most part, what they were trying to do against the Blue Jackets: get pucks behind the defense, make good decisions and limit the Columbus transition game.
Ultimately, the difference proved to be the man in net.
"We had a number of opportunities," Bylsma said. "Just couldn't crack it."