That lead, like the other two, however, would not hold. Kane floated a backhand in front of the net and then with 2:04 remaining in regulation, Anismiov knocked in a rebound for his second of the night to force overtime.
While O'Reilly picked up a pair of assists in his return to the lineup after missing the past for games due to an appendectomy, it's a play in overtime that will stick with him.
Toward the end of his shift, O'Reilly decided to drive down the right wing with the puck to try and generate a scoring chance. He ended up losing the puck behind the net and Chicago started back up on the rush, leading to Kane's game winner.
"It was a bad decision by myself. I had possession of the puck. I think I should've curled up, kept possession and we should've changed," O'Reilly said. "It's just a bad play by myself. I just tried to hold the puck, just tried to get around him. It probably wasn't the smartest play. From there, it was just a transition. I was gassed. I put us in a bad spot, giving them a 3-on-2. It's frustrating. The game was there for us and we could've won."
Buffalo did collect three of four points on the trip and head back home as they prepare for a Saturday afternoon game against the Winnipeg Jets at KeyBank Center.
"We definitely showed a lot of resiliency. It's just tough," Eichel said. "We all really wanted that second point and I almost think it's been the tale of our season. We get to these situations and we're not able to put a stamp on the game. It's why we find ourselves out of the playoffs and far back. It's disappointing."