While a number of Sabres had grade-A chances that didn't materialize, Sheary stood out in particular as one whose standout performance was stifled by Holtby. He was stopped on a breakaway, had a deflection robbed from point-blank range and saw the puck poked away at the offensive blue line.
On that third play, Holtby all the way out above the circle to challenge a Rasmus Ristolainen breakaway. After blocking Ristolainen's attempt, he knocked the puck away from Sheary and out of play. Sheary was asked if he could have done anything differently.
"I mean, maybe a little bit more poise with him being all the way out at the blue line," he said. "But when you're in the moment and you see the goalie out there, you're just trying to get it to the net and hopefully something good happens."
Still, the Sabres kept pushing. They played their best hockey in the third period, outshooting the Capitals 17-8 in the process.
"I think we were just playing on our toes," Sheary said. "Sometimes when you play a team like this, you give them a lot of respect with the success they've had. I think we kind of took it to them there. We know we're a good team here, so I think that's good confidence for us moving forward."
As frustrating as two close losses in the same building can be, Sheary - who had plenty of battles with the Capitals during his tenure in Pittsburgh - put them in perspective. Outcome aside, they once again showed they can compete with the best.
"It's frustrating, but we also have to understand that's a good team over there," he said. "They took advantage of their opportunities and they scored one more than us.
"I think we have a quick turnaround here, we've got to have a fresh mindset tomorrow and work as hard as we did. Hopefully we'll come out with a better result."