"I think it was a case where we duplicated jobs in some of the wrong areas of the rink," says Pens coach Mike Sullivan of the number of odd-man rushes his team allowed in the first. "We got caught into the piles and as a result, we didn't support one another. If a [defenseman] is going down the wall to keep a puck alive, we've got to make sure we get a reload; we stay on the right side of people, we stay on the right side of the puck. I thought we fell victim to that in particular in the first period."
In the second, the Caps killed off a Pittsburgh power play early in the frame, and then weathered a late surge from their hosts. Holtby stopped Jared McCann on a breakaway with 1:12 left, but officials also awarded McCann a penalty shot on the same play. The Pittsburgh forward teed up another chance from the red line, and Holtby stopped that one, too.
In the waning seconds of the frame, a goalmouth scramble took place in front of the Washington net, and Brenden Dillon was busted for knocking the net off its moorings, one of the better penalties the Caps have taken recently. Pittsburgh got a carryover power play, and the Caps carried a 3-0 lead to the third.
Washington promptly extended its advantage with a shorthanded strike in the first minute, as Carl Hagelin set up Dowd's second of the game on another 2-on-1 rush at the Pittsburgh at :34 of the third to make it a 4-0 game.
Pittsburgh finally broke Holtby's spell when Crosby scored from the top of the paint at 5:09, and Holtby prevented the Pens from seizing momentum with a pair of stellar stops on Patrick Marleau on the very next shift.
The Pens eventually cut the lead to 4-2 when Malkin scored a power-play goal at 12:16.
Pittsburgh possesses more than enough firepower to comeback from multi-goal deficits, but the Caps quickly responded to dash any local hopes of such a turnabout. Less than a minute after Malkin's marker, Backstrom set up Oshie for a slot shot, and he didn't miss. His one-timer beat Murray to make it 5-2 at 13:12.
Saturday's victory pushes the Caps five points ahead of the third-place Penguins in the Metro Division standings. The two teams will meet one more time here in Pittsburgh, two weeks from tomorrow on March 22.
"I think the win means a lot," says Oshie, "but I think the way we played means more. Obviously we give up a couple there late, but from the top all the way down, everyone had the same effort tonight. Dowder's line and Lars [Eller's] line, they bring that effort every night. When we get the top two [lines] working that same way, we're going to have success and we're going to be hard to beat."