From the outside, there is a tendency to make sweeping judgments and concoct grand plans. Goaltenders could net a relatively high return! The Golden Knights should take lots of goaltenders! If they take lots of goaltenders, they will both create a market and corner it!
In reality, it hasn't worked like that.
Asked if any particular group of players was in high demand, like goaltenders or defensemen, McPhee said: "You know, I anticipated that question, and it's really all over the place. Managers have different holes they want to fill, and so the requests have come in. And some of them are interesting, because it's not someone that we were going to claim but it fits for their team."
Asked if he could manipulate the trade market, McPhee said: "Yeah, I don't know if we're smart enough to really complicate things too much, and this is a complicated process."
McPhee has listened to his counterparts. He has gotten a sense of the market and taken it for what it is, not what he thinks it should be. Now he's running an auction. If teams are bidding on an exposed player, or if he is going to take an exposed player himself, McPhee is being direct with the GM of that player's team. Want to keep him? Here's what it's going to take.
"We're basically saying, 'Do you want to hear what's going on with your team, or are you just content to sit and we're going to do what we're going to do?' " McPhee said. "Most of them want to talk about it, and then we tell them exactly what's going on. 'Is there something you want to do about it or not?' "
By the time McPhee and his staff sit down Tuesday, they will have all the data they need to make their final decisions. By the time McPhee sleeps on it Tuesday night, there should be no phone call unmade, no detail undiscussed, no potential deal undone.
He ought to sleep like a baby.