That's likely what it will be whenever he's done, but it's way more interesting to play the Sid vs. Mario game.
"It's not fair," said Phil Bourque, a former Penguins defenseman and current Penguins radio analyst. "But it makes for a fun conversation, a good read."
Crosby, of course, won't fuel it. He'll turn 30 in August and is old enough to leave a legacy if he retired today, but too young to spend much time thinking about what he's done. For now, he says, all he cares about is being a good teammate and a good pro.
"I just try to make sure as a group we're in it together and that I'm leading by example," he said.
Which brings us back to last season. Crosby led by example and helped carry the Penguins to the top. In the process he said the run made him appreciate the grind of the playoffs, especially overcoming injuries and adversity, more than he had in the previous six years.
Crosby hadn't gone through a full playoff run since 2009, when the Penguins won their first Stanley Cup with him as captain.
"When you win right away you just remember that last series, the feeling of winning, all that is fresh in your mind," he said. "When you have time to let it sink in you realize that everything wasn't just perfect along the way. It feels that way when you win. It feels that everything came together. But there were some challenges along the way that we had to overcome."