At first, Crosby said Washington's success shouldn't add any juice to what's already a heated rivalry, but then he smiled and kept talking. As he did, it became clear that he, like Malkin, thinks it absolutely does elevate what might be the best rivalry in the NHL.
"I think that'll definitely light a fire for us," Crosby said. "That's on your mind when you play that team again. It's just the way it is. That's the way it is when you lose. You've always kind of got that feeling of something to prove and when you win, you've got that feeling of, hey, we've got to stay here. That's just the two sides of it. But yeah, that's kind of the approach."
Malkin said he thinks Washington's success last season will also change how each side views the rivalry, because now it's not nearly as one-sided as it used to be.
"We win last year and they win this year," he said. "It's two winners playing against each other and they hate each other."
The talk of a repeat coming out of Washington is also familiar to Malkin and Crosby, who were saying similar things after winning in 2016.
They're ready to put an end to it.
"We see what they say, that they want the same, back to back, that they want to win again," Malkin said. "We understand they try. They want to be in history too. They don't want it just one time, they want it two times. We understand we're a team that can stop them."
NHL.com columnist Nick Cotsonika contributed to this story.