Keegan Kolesar also scored, and Theodore had two assists for the Golden Knights (19-7-3), who have won four straight. Adin Hill made 18 saves.
“(We were) able to tie it up, then go down again, we stayed with it right to the very end,” Kolesar said. “We didn't let it waver in any way in our play, played right to the whistle and we were able to come up two points.”
Josh Morrissey and Nikita Chibrikov scored for the Jets (21-9-1), who are 3-1-1 in their past five. Connor Hellebuyck made 34 saves.
“We didn’t like our first two periods,” Morrissey said. “They’re obviously a very good team, but we’re still up 1-0 going into the third. … (We) did a decent job through the third period, I thought, of trying to play our game when we didn’t really have our best stuff in the first two. Obviously, a tough ending with the penalties there at the end of the game. It was a tough situation, and we couldn’t get it done in OT.”
Chibrikov gave the Jets a 1-0 lead at 9:27 of the first period. Vladislav Namestnikov’s shot on the rush was kicked aside by Hill, finding Chibrikov at the left side of the net for a tap in. He has a goal in each of his first three NHL games.
"I think that [Chibrikov] is growing, he's learning every game, every shift,” Winnipeg coach Scott Arniel said. “He's competitive, he goes to those areas, he drove to that net on that goal tonight. He does a lot of good things. Lots of times, you're concerned that maybe without the puck, he might be a liability, but that line had lots of good looks. They had some zone time and that's what you hope for when a guy like that goes in there."