The lead was short lived as Edmonton responded 36 seconds later. Warren Foegele skated the puck into the Avalanche's defensive zone and sent a horizontal pass to Ryan McLeod in the right faceoff circle. McLeod dropped a pass to above the circle for Ekholm, who blasted his one-timer shot past Georgiev for the 1-1 equalizer at 5:28.
The first period's sleepy start didn't carry over as the intensity amplified in the second period, despite the score remaining 1-1. The Oilers carried much of the puck possession and held a 17-7 shot advantage as they finished the frame with six - unsuccessful - minutes on the power play.
Early in the middle frame both teams had unsuccessful power play attempts (Klim Kostin delay of game at 2:30 and Bowen Byram slashing at 5:16), but both sides continued to generate chances. Just over the 11-minute mark, Connor McDavid was sprung on a breakaway. As the NHL's leading scorer (152 points, 64 goals) approached Georgiev his stickhandling lost momentum and the Avalanche netminder was able to deny the chance.
Late in the frame at 14:46, Devon Toews was sent to the box for a four-minute double minor for high-sticking on Zach Hyman, as Toews' stick struck Hyman's chin and drew blood. The Avalanche's penalty kill came up with an extraordinary effort against Edmonton's league-leading power play (32.5%), including an effort where Logan O'Connor blocked a shot on the inside of the leg and remained in long enough for Colorado to clear the puck out of the zone.
As the penalty expired, the atmosphere at Ball Arena was electric as they backed the team for the momentous kill.
Both sides battled hard in the third period as they exerted yet another intense, tight-checking effort, but neither side was able to add the go-ahead strike. Georgiev continued his sensational effort and even garnered "Geor-gie!" chants from the crowd.
Colorado received two power plays in the final frame - at 4:40 on McLeod and at 14:53 on Kane as both were called for high sticking - but despite some lethal looks, the Avalanche's power play was unable to solve Skinner.