His best stop of the night was in the middle frame as he denied Taylor Hall's rebound chance in front with a sprawling save.
"I thought he was fantastic," Avs head coach Jared Bednar said of his starter. "He was our best player by a country mile."
You could hardly blame him on the other two goals against.
The next marker came after he was squarely screened in front and couldn't see an outside shot by Andy Greene midway through the second period. The call on the ice was originally ruled no goal due to goaltender interference, but the Devils used their challenge and the play was eventually overturned.
"I spoke to the ref, and he said if that guy bumps me at the same time the puck goes in, it's no goal," Smith noted afterward. "But they said they looked at the replay and the puck went in just a half-second before, which is the right call. He did his job screening me, so hat's off for him."
The last tally of the night with 3:35 left in the middle stanza was the result of some nice passing during a 2-on-1 rush and ended with Kyle Palmieri tapping in the puck on a late feed.
"I played for the Palmieri shot and then I got over for the Hall shot," Smith said. "He made a great play backdoor. That's another one where we'll look at the video and see if I can get over quicker or if there's anything I can do differently."
Bednar called it a bad break as the puck jumped over Matt Nieto's stick at the left wall in the New Jersey end and resulted in the rush the other way.
"Everyone was already heading toward the net. When it jumped over his stick, their guy just chipped it by him and he was gone by him and Barberio," Bednar said. "They got caught in a tough spot because of that puck."
Signed as a free agent on July 1, Smith began the year in San Antonio to help provide organizational depth at the goaltending position. He put together a 5-8-1 record, 2.57 goals-against average and .911 save percentage in 17 games with the Rampage before being recalled by the Avs for the second time this season last Wednesday.
He had played the role of backup goalie eight times this season behind Calvin Pickard, including the last three outings.
But not this night. As the team took the ice for warmup, it was Smith leading them out. It was also his teammates that held on the bench as the netminder unknowingly took one lap around the ice alone, partly as a prank and partly as a way to give him his time in the spotlight.
He certainly earned it and is hopeful for many more moments like it.
"It's been a long 27 years but today it's just not the end. It's just the beginning," Smith said.