In our consensus poll that mixed together the rankings of 15 different draft experts, Fantilli checked in as the second-best prospect in the draft, and a sample of their descriptions of the pivot reveal they all like his well-rounded game. Scott Wheeler of The Athletic says, "The physical element that he has, that fiery competitiveness that he has, his upside is ultimately just a touch higher than those (other prospects)." Chris Peters of FloHockey adds, "Adam Fantilli has so many traits of a No. 1 center that you say, 'This guy is going to set us up for a long time.'" And Dan Marr, the head of NHL Central Scouting, notes, "It was truly exceptional what he was able to accomplish this year."