Columbus needed just one shift of the game to get on the board, getting the puck in deep and scoring when Sillinger passed the puck off the right wall to the onrushing Chinakhov, who ripped a wrist shot off the bar and in past Stars goalie Remi Poirier. Dallas replied with a pair of goals from first-round pick Wyatt Johnson, but Columbus made it 2-2 with 11.3 seconds left in the period when Gaudet protected the puck well along the right side and shot the puck, where it flipped off the stick of a Stars defenseman and over Poirier's shoulder.
Dallas started the second period well and took a 3-2 lead 5:16 into the period when Jacob Peterson slipped the puck under the legs of CBJ goalie Greaves on the power play. But Greaves rebounded to make an incredible post-to-post save on Thomas Harley to keep it a one-goal game, which proved fortuitous when Sillinger scored at 4-on-4 with 2:57 left in the frame, ripping a shot on the rush past the blocker of Poirier.
Columbus didn't waste long breaking the tie and taking a 4-3 lead in the third period. With Columbus on the power play, Sillinger flipped the puck to Chinakhov on the right wing, and he had plenty of time and space to rip a shot past the glove of Poirier. Columbus then iced the game with 11:27 to go as Gaudet scored on a delayed penalty when Tristan Mullin took a high stick to the face that required treatment.