Before long, Bieber responded with his own counter offer: "How bout 10 thousand dollars to charity (if) I score on you and you donate to a charity of my choice and we film it."
For those out there wondering, Binnington has accepted Bieber's proposal.
Exactly when, where and what charity will benefit has yet to be determined, but it's likely the breakaway challenge will happen sometime during the offseason.
For the record, Bieber will make a stop in St. Louis for his 2020 Tour on July 13 at Enterprise Center. Perhaps that will give us a chance to settle this once and for all.
Can a musician that has sold more than 140 million albums score on a Stanley Cup champion?
We'll have to wait and see.