After a high-event first frame that featured 36 shots (18 on each side), 32 hits, five penalties and four goals, the second period was scoreless but not bereft of "events." Boston had the only power play of the period, but a total of six minor penalties were whistled in a span of roughly three and a half minutes in the back half of the frame. Each time, the officials opted to take a player from each side, so there was a fair amount of 4-on-4 hockey.
Washington lost Eller to a lower body injury midway through the second, leaving the Caps down a forward and without a critical centerman the rest of the way.
In the third, the Caps failed to convert on a pair of early and nearly consecutive power plays, but they managed to take their first lead of the night just seconds after the expiration of the second of those man advantages.
Carl Hagelin made a nifty bump pass to Orlov just on the Boston side of neutral ice, sending the Washington blueliner into the Bruins' zone on a 2-on-1 with Hathaway riding shotgun. Orlov sold the possibility of the shot to Rask, then issued a perfect feed for Hathaway, who buried a wrist shot from the right circle for a 3-2 Caps lead at 7:04 of the third.
Washington tried to whittle the clock away. It got pucks deep routinely and consistently, but it was rarely able to hang onto them for very long in the Bruins' zone. The B's kept pressing for the equalizer and with just under three minutes left in regulation, they tied it up on a goalmouth scramble, with Taylor Hall jamming it behind Anderson in the midst of a pileup of humanity atop the blue paint.
"There was a pretty good scrum going on there," says Laviolette. "There had to be eight people down in there by the end of it. It pops out and you hack and whack. We're trying to hack and whack and get it out of there or tie it up somehow. It popped to [Hall] and he whacked it."
Monday's game is the 11th straight one-goal playoff game between the Caps and the Bruins, extending an NHL record. The streak dates back to the first round of the 1998 Stanley Cup Playoffs. Neither team has led by more than a goal at any point in the first two games, and the teams traded goals until Hathaway scored consecutive goals for Washington a period and a half apart to give the Caps the lead.
The Bruins scored the next two to tie it late and win it in overtime.
"I think the guys that have been here understood the urgency of this game," says Boston coach Bruce Cassidy. "We had to play better; we did. Obviously getting the win is very important, but for our own selves, we needed to play a better hockey game. I thought we were the better team tonight and were full value for the win."