Washington took advantage of an early power play opportunity to get a leg up on the Rangers. Oshie made a good play to flag down a Trouba clearing try, preventing New York from getting a change, and then both Oshie and Alex Ovechkin made strong plays to keep the puck in the Rangers' zone. With Oshie parked on the doorstep, Nicklas Backstrom floated a pass his way. Oshie fired two or three times from point blank range on Lundqvist, who couldn't manage to corral the puck. Eventually, it went in off the skate of Blueshirts blueliner Marc Staal at 2:24 of the first, credited to Oshie as an unassisted power-play goal.
New York got even on a power play of its own at 12:25 of the initial period. Mika Zibanejad made a nifty play out of the right-wing corner, feeding Pavel Buchnevich in the slot. Buchnevich got Holtby to commit, then lifted the puck over him into a yawning cage to knot the score.
Less than three minutes later, the Caps regained their lead. Carlson put a center point drive toward the net, but it was blocked by the Rangers defense. Ovechkin collected it and shot, and Lundqvist made the save, but pushed the rebound directly to Kempny, who promptly buried it at 15:16, putting the Caps back on top, 2-1.
Early in the second, the Caps went up by two on a strong shift in the offensive zone from the fourth line. Dmitry Orlov put a shot squarely off the left pipe, and bounced right to Nic Dowd, who didn't miss, potting his first of the season at 3:45 to make it a 3-1 game.