Washington had some early chances in the second, and Hawks goalie Marc-Andre Fleury made a dazzling stop on Lars Eller from in tight, preventing the Caps from taking the lead. The Caps went cold thereafter, going more than nine minutes without a shot on net in the middle of the middle frame.
Meanwhile, the Hawks regained the lead late in a power play. With Dowd off for roughing, the Caps survived most of the kill. Kuznetsov got control of the puck and exited the Washington zone, but didn't get it deep, which would have killed off most - if not all - of the remainder of the penalty. Instead, the Hawks were able to make a quick change and come right back into Washington ice, and they scored with 11 seconds left on the penalty. Fresh-legged Chicago forward Dominik Kubalik scored the goal at 12:57 of the second, four seconds after he hopped over the boards.
The Caps drew even once again, doing so on a broken play a few minutes after the Kubalik strike. After dumping the puck into the Hawks' end, the Caps went in on the forecheck. Alex Ovechkin hustled down the right side to get to the puck, and he threw a pass across for Aliaksei Protas at the far post. The puck deflected off the traffic in front and pinged the far post, and was wobbling on the wrong side of the line until Kuznetsov swooped in and swept it home, tying the game at 2-2 at 17:31.
Hathaway was boxed soon after, and he finished serving his sentence in the early seconds of the third. As he exited the box, Dowd spotted him and fed him perfectly, and his goal at the 57-second mark of the third gave Washington the lead. But for the third straight game, the Caps let a third-period lead slip away.
With just over eight minutes remaining, Jones hopped over the boards and cruised into the high slot, took a feed from Josiah Slavin and beat Vitek Vanecek to knot the game at 11:56.
"It was a great play by Slave to drive it down and stop up," recounts Jones. "It pushed everyone down low in the slot. Then I came off the bench and definitely saw a lane. I was calling for it, and he put it right on my tape. I just wanted to finish it."
"It was a missed coverage on the third [Chicago] goal," explains Laviolette. "I think we had someone there, and they drifted off to the side and it ended up leaving a hole down the middle of the ice.