Just over three minutes later, the Leafs responded. The Caps left Kapanen with too much time and space in front, and Boyle and Martin did the necessary wall work and got the puck to him. Kapanen beat Holtby with a backhander from in tight at 14:25, but Washington issued its coach's video challenge, alleging the play was offside.
The subsequent review showed that the play was very close, close enough to compel a challenge, but the goal was upheld and the game was square at 2-2 late in the second.
Caps defenseman Dmitry Orlov hauled Bozak down behind the Washington net with 31.6 seconds left in the second, putting the Leafs on their fourth power play of the night. Toronto needed only a few seconds of the minor with which to regain the lead; Morgan Rielly floated a wrist shot through heavy traffic that found purchase behind Holtby, leaving the Leafs up 3-2 at 19:46 of the second.
Having lost defenseman Roman Polak - who left the game late in the second period after landing awkwardly following a Brooks Orpik bodycheck - the Leafs were down to five blueliners as the third period got underway.
An absolutely dominant offensive zone shift enabled Washington to even the game at 3-3 at the 12:39 mark of the third. Eller started the shift with some beastly work at holding onto and protecting the puck, and the Caps were able to get a full personnel change without losing possession in the Toronto zone. Orlov did some excellent work to keep the puck in at the left point, and he kept control while walking the line to the middle of the ice. From there, he fired a slap pass down low on the left side, and Nicklas Backstrom deposited it behind Andersen to make it a 3-3 game at 12:39 of the third.