It looked like the Islanders had the game under control at 3-0, but the Capitals responded with a flurry of goals in the second period, scoring five times in a 9:23 span to take a 5-3 lead.
It happened fast, with Washington scoring three goals in 2:04 to turn a 3-0 game into a 3-3 deadlock. Conor Sheary put the first crack in the dam, collecting a blocked point shot in the slot, turning and flinging it past Semyon Varlamov at 9:07. Roughly 73 seconds - and two icings later - Sheary had his second goal, deflecting a Zdeno Chara point shot past Varlamov at 10:20 on a play that started with a defensive-zone draw for the Islanders.
"You see some long shifts, a couple of icings in there, a couple where we didn't get the puck out, or make plays at the red line to get it deep," Scott Mayfield said. "Those long shifts wear you down and they put a couple in. That lapse there kind of summed up the game."
Shortly after, Garnet Hathaway tied the score at 11:11, beating Varlamov under the arm off the rush. The tying goal prompted Trotz to use his timeout, but it did not have the calming or reversing effect. John Carlson capped some Capitals pressure with a power-play goal, beating Varlamov with a one-timer at 14:16. Chara made it 5-3 with his first as a Capital - a trademark bullet - at 18:30.
The five-goal period left the Islanders shell-shocked by the end of the middle frame, as it marked just the second time the Islanders had allowed five in a period under Trotz. The last time, Jan. 18, 2020 against the Capitals.
"It's a tough one because we didn't play that poorly for 50 minutes of that game, but a 2-3 minute span we were below average," Trotz said. "I didn't think we were as bad as that, but it all happened all at once and you get into stunned mode. Our poise, our confidence has been rattled and we need to pull that together. We're not going to get outside help. It's the group has to pull together."
After a sideways second period, where the Capitals scored five of their 14 shots, Trotz opted to go back to Varlamov in the third period, as opposed to Cory Schneider, who was backing up.
Down two goals, the Islanders were on the offensive in the third period, while the Capitals were content to clog the middle of the ice and slow things down. It resulted in an 11-1 shot-on-goal advantage for the Islanders, and no action for Varlamov, as the lone Washington shot was an empty-netter for Tom Wilson.
Trotz said he thought about going to Schneider, but didn't hang the loss on Varlamov and wanted to give his workhorse a vote of confidence.