The second period was filled with special teams. San Jose was whistled for three minor penalties and Tampa Bay was whistled for two, but neither team had a two-man advantage at any point. In total, 8:05 of the second period was played with one team on a power play.
The Lightning's power play was getting some looks, but were unable to convert, while the Sharks scored on their third power-play opportunity of the night, again just five seconds into the man advantage. The period ended with the Bolts still maintaining a one-goal lead going into the third period on home ice, a situation where the team has typically performed strongly. The Lightning were 17-1-1 when leading after two periods prior to Tuesday's contest.
Cooper was very pleased with the opening 20 minutes and the response his team gave following Monday's disappointing loss to Florida. But, from there, things went sideways.
"It was an unreal response," Cooper said. "I thought we came out and dictated play and did everything we wanted to do for 20 minutes.
"Then, special teams took over and we lost the special teams game. That was it."
San Jose tied the game 3:08 into the third period when a shot from the point changed directions on multiple occasions with a couple deflections and snuck past Brian Elliott to make it a 3-3 game. Tampa Bay failed to find the back of the net for the remainder of the period and surrendered a breakaway to Meier with about one minute remaining in regulation. Fortunately for the Bolts, his shot rang off the goal post.
From there, the game advanced to overtime before Karlsson found Meier for his second goal of the contest and the game-winning goal at the 2:19 mark of the extra frame.
"We gave up a breakaway in regulation with 10 seconds left to a really good player," Cooper said. "I sit here and say, 'Well, I think we're fortunate we got a point out of this game.'
"Let's take that and move on, but no question, an extremely disappointing loss for our group."
Things won't get any easier with the Lightning's upcoming schedule. Tampa Bay will face the Colorado Avalanche in a Stanley Cup Final rematch at AMALIE Arena on Thursday night before taking off for a nine-day, four-game road trip with games against Dallas, Colorado, Arizona and Vegas.