For the third consecutive season, the Calgary Flames will have two new goaltenders. Mike Smith was acquired in a trade with the Arizona Coyotes on June 17, and Eddie Lack in a trade with the Carolina Hurricanes on June 29.
On the surface, they don't appear to be an upgrade over last season's tandem of Brian Elliott (who signed as a free agent with the Philadelphia Flyers) and Chad Johnson (who was traded to the Arizona Coyotes, then signed with the Buffalo Sabres as an unrestricted free agent). Over the past three seasons, Elliott and Johnson have even-strength save percentages of .925 and .919; Smith and Lack are .920 and .913.
Digging deeper into shot-quality factors that can influence a goalie's save percentage reveals that Smith's and Lack's numbers have been affected to a greater extent than most. Rather than treat all shots equally, Alan Ryder created a version of save percentage in 2004 that assigns a value to each shot based on where it was taken. Goalies are evaluated relative to how an NHL-average goalie would have performed against the same quality of shots.
Based on an updated version of this statistic provided by the analyst at Don't Tell Me About Heart, Smith's even-strength save percentage is .0030 above average, and Lack's is above by .0016.