The Capitals will never get a better opportunity than they had Wednesday to take control of the series.
The Penguins were missing center Sidney Crosby, their best player and arguably the best player in the world, and right wing Conor Sheary after each sustained a concussion in Game 3. They were also missing their top defenseman, Kris Letang, who had season-ending neck surgery, and Matt Murray, who was their No. 1 goaltender before sustaining a lower-body injury during warmups before Game 1 of their first-round series against the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Fortunately for the Penguins, they had veteran Marc-Andre Fleury waiting to take over in net, and he frustrated the Capitals again in Game 4 by making 36 saves to negate Washington's 38-18 advantage in shots on goal.
"We had some good chances we didn't bury, and we're sitting here now down 3-1," Capitals coach Barry Trotz said. "Now our backs are against the wall and the next game is the most important game of the year, and if we don't have the urgency that we need in that game, then we don't earn the right to keep playing. So we have to wrap our arms around the reality of that."
Trotz declined to blame the Capitals' struggles on a mental block against Fleury or against the Penguins in general.
"Right now, we've got to find an extra way to get an extra goal, we've got to get an extra save, and our top guys tonight weren't as good as they needed to be," he said. "You get an opportunity to play well, [and] I didn't think our top guys really stepped up tonight, which was very unfortunate for us."
Trotz wouldn't single out Ovechkin when asked specifically about him, instead grouping him with the rest of the Capitals' top players.
"They need to be top players and step up right now," Trotz said.
If they don't, then their season will be over.
"The mindset is win or have the same result as last year," Williams said.