Along with the Calder Trophy, Alfredsson also won the King Clancy Memorial Trophy in 2011-12, which is awarded to the player who best exemplifies leadership qualities on and off the ice and has made a noteworthy humanitarian contribution in their community, and the Mark Messier NHL Leadership Award in 2012-13.
Although he played his final season with the Detroit Red Wings in 2013-14, getting 49 points (18 goals, 31 assists) in 68 games, Alfredsson returned to Ottawa on Dec. 4, 2014, to retire as a Senator. He then had his No. 11 retired on Dec. 29, 2016.
Alfredsson had a distinguished body of work on the international stage with Sweden as well, including winning the gold medal at the 2006 Turin Olympics and the silver medal at the 2014 Sochi Olympics.
Despite all that, Alfredsson, who was in his fifth year of Hall of Fame eligibility, wasn't expecting a call on Monday from Hall of Fame chairman Lanny McDonald and selection committee chairman Mike Gartner.
"It was after 8 o'clock local time here, I thought it's not going to happen this year," he said. "But they called and my wife answered the phoned and asked, 'Who's calling?' A very pleasant surprise, extremely honored."
Senators fans had organized a robust campaign to have Alfredsson elected to the Hall, and the graceful former captain chuckled about the idea that they had finally managed to get the job done.
"I would like to think that it was my playing career that made them select me," he said with a laugh. "But it really does feel truly special to have the support not only from the group that put this (election) bid together, but also all the fans who responded.
"When you do retire, it feels even more special to be able to have the connection that I've had with the city and the fans, even after my playing days. That means a lot. I think a lot of fans of the Senators are very happy today as well to see me get this recognition. They're a big part of it.
"We play our careers, we do the best we can, we're professionals, we take pride in what we do. When we hang them up, we hang them up. We can't control what happens after that.
"But it's really a humbling honor to get this when you think of the people who were there before, and especially to get this recognition in a Canadian market where I played the majority of my career, knowing how much hockey means to the city, I know how much this recognition will means to the fans of Ottawa as well. It's truly humbling."