The night ended well, but it did not get off to a great start for Matthews. He was partly responsible for forward Anthony Mantha's goal that gave Detroit a 1-0 lead at 5:33 of the second period. After losing a puck battle to forward Henrik Zetterberg at the Maple Leafs blue line, Matthews inadvertently ended up screening goaltender Frederik Andersen while trying to block Mantha's shot. But when Toronto erupted for four goals in the third period, capped by Matthews' first of the game at 12:05 to make it 4-1, he figured he helped put the game out of reach.
But when Detroit responded with three goals in the final 6:06, including Mantha's tying goal with 1.1 seconds remaining, it was Matthews' line that was on the ice for the tying goal. Maple Leafs coach Mike Babcock, always striving to keep his players honest, made sure he pointed out the whole story after the game while still giving credit to Matthews for his overtime heroics.
"[Matthews] played head to head with [Zetterberg's] line," Babcock said. "[Zetterberg] had three points, Mantha had three points. They were good too, so let's not get carried away here. Auston and his linemates were on the ice at the end when Detroit had a board across our blue line and we couldn't quite get it across. We got a lesson here tonight, but we were still able to win the game for our fans."
But as great players seem to do on the biggest stages, Matthews delivered at 3:40 of overtime when the game was on the line, scoring his second of the game and 20th goal, tying Los Angeles Kings forward Jeff Carter for the second-most in the League this season.