Tavares said the issue of the captaincy did not come up during his negotiations with Toronto.
That hasn't stopped former Maple Leafs captains from offering their opinion in the debate this offseason.
During an interview with TSN 1050 Toronto on May 26, five weeks before Tavares signed, Mats Sundin said Matthews should not be a sure bet for the captaincy.
"It's easy to say Auston Matthews, he should be the captain," said Sundin, who was Maple Leafs captain from 1997-2008. "But saying that, it has to be a player and a person that also wants to carry that responsibility and actually plays better wearing the C.
"Most of the great leaders I played with, they lead by example, they lead by the way they play on the ice, they compete the most, they treat their players in their dressing room in a very professional way, they treat everybody the same, whether you're a player, or equipment manager, or the person down in the garage where you park your car. They are professional off the ice, they're first in the gym. You want that kind of culture as your leader, and when you have someone like that ... especially if you have the highest-paid guy, or one of your star players, the rest of the team's going to follow that. When I look at a leader, that's what I want to see."