Nelson gave the Islanders a 1-0 lead at 5:57 of the first period. Pierre Engvall won a battle along the boards with Connor Clifton and got the puck to Nelson, who scored glove side from the left circle.
“I just tried to hunt the puck down,” Engvall said. “I don’t know what I was thinking. I'm just trying to get the puck, and I felt that I had a step on him, and I was lucky he fell. I might’ve tripped him. We got the puck out there, and Nelson scored a really nice goal.”
Palmieri was credited with the goal that made it 2-0 at 18:18. Nelson got to a rebound in front, and his shot deflected off Palmieri and the skate of Clifton before redirecting into the net.
Greenway cut it to 2-1 at 4:15 of the second period. He took a pass from Mittelstadt on a 2-on-1, cut back across the crease, and slid the puck into an open net.
Benson, who was selected with the No. 13 pick in the 2023 NHL draft, had the secondary assist on the play for his first NHL point.
Mittelstadt tied it 2-2 with a backhand near the left post at 2:34 of the third period.
"I thought the second was kind of where we started to get going," Mittelstadt said. "Making plays and playing fast, I thought we looked like ourselves from there on in. ... Obviously it was a tough ending, but we know it's early and there's definitely some positive things we can take away from it."
Cizikas responded by redirecting Adam Pelech's point shot at 13:40 to put New York back in front 3-2.
“Pelech did a great job walking the line and getting that puck through,” Cizikas said. “That’s the main thing. It’s not easy. Guys are in front of pucks, guys are committed to blocking them. To get that puck through the bodies, it was definitely a great play by him.”