All these years later, Cole, who spent four decades covering hockey greats in Edmonton, Toronto, Vancouver and everywhere in between, will join those wordsmiths he so admired, being named the 2017 recipient of the Ferguson Award. In typical Cole modesty, he's not sure he belongs.
The voters certainly thought he does.
"I keep thinking someone is going to do a recount," Cole said. "I mean, it's still hard to grasp.
"I can't describe what it means. If someone said to me that someday I would have my own little entry among these greats of our profession, I would have said: 'Come on, be serious.' I mean, we're talking about some of the greatest writers ever."
The Elmer Ferguson Memorial Award is by the Hockey Hall of Fame, "in recognition of distinguished members of the newspaper profession whose words have brought honor to journalism and to hockey." Recipients are selected by the Professional Hockey Writers' Association.
"I remember that day I saw some of the pictures of the past winners," Cole said. "That was so sweet. It was incredible to see them there. But it's beyond incredible to think my picture will be there beside them."
Wayne Gretzky says Cole belongs in that group.
"Cam deserves to be there," Gretzky, the NHL's all-time leading scorer, said. "He worked hard. He earned it."
Cole's 41-year career in sports writing began after he left Vegreville, Alberta to attend the University of Alberta, where he worked for the college newspaper, The Gateway. He began covering high school sports, soccer and the Alberta Junior Hockey League for the Edmonton Journal, putting him in place to chronicle the Edmonton Oilers' dynasty years as the paper's general sports columnist.