Tony DeAngelo had a goal and an assist for the Hurricanes (31-9-3), who had won four in a row. Andersen, who played the previous five seasons for the Maple Leafs, made 28 saves in his return to Toronto.
"I think it's tough to get too emotional in these circumstances," Andersen said. "It was nice of them to kind of say thanks for the time here, and then I moved on and focused on the game again. It's a little bit weird, but eventually the game has to come first, so it was back to focusing on that."
Hurricanes coach Rod Brind'Amour said he had no complaints about his team despite surrendering a third-period lead.
"It was a good game," he said. "I thought we played well. I'm not disappointed at all in our effort or anything. Obviously, you'd love the two points, but for not having any power plays, I just thought we created a lot of offense, especially in the second period, where we had four or five breakaways and 2-on-1's that we didn't cash in on and it could have been a different game there.
"Give the players credit on both teams. It's a dead building and these guys played hard tonight. I thought it was a good game."