But Kane, who is eighth in the NHL with 63 points (25 goals, 38 assists) this season, understood it was all in good fun. And although the 31-year-old right wing wasn't sure what to make of the Gatorade NHL Shooting Stars, he enjoyed winning it.
The event involved 10 players positioned on an elevated platform behind the goal, approximately 30 feet above the ice surface, shooting seven pucks at a variety of targets located on the ice, with each target possessing point values ranging from one point to a 10-point target shaped like the Gateway Arch at center ice.
"I think it's a little bit of luck," Kane said. "We kind of had a pact we're not just going to try to sauce them into the three-pointers and go for the ones up front. We were all going to try to shoot for the Arch."
That was the case in the tiebreaker, too. Kane, O'Reilly and Marner each aimed for the Arch with their extra shot and missed, but Kane's shot bounced and hit a two-point target behind.
"We were kind of joking around I sealed it with a two-pointer," Kane said. "The other guys went for the 10. I went for the 10. They just kind of missed and mine bounced over and hit the two-pointer, so I think it's a little bit of luck, too."
The win capped off a big day for Kane, who earlier was named to the NHL All-Decade First Team along with Blackhawks defenseman Duncan Keith, Pittsburgh Penguins center Sidney Crosby, Washington Capitals left wing Alex Ovechkin, Los Angeles Kings defenseman Drew Doughty and Vegas Golden Knights goalie Marc-Andre Fleury.
The six players were chosen by a panel of NHL general managers, NHL hockey operations staff, NHL.com writers, and on-air talent from NBC, Sportsnet and TVA Sports.
"It's a great honor," said Kane, who recorded his 1,000th NHL point with an assist against the Winnipeg Jets on Jan. 19. "Ten years is a long time to be a good player and it's a tribute to myself being consistent but also the teams I've been playing on. I've played on some amazing teams. I'm very fortunate that some of our playoff runs -- five conference finals, three Stanley Cups, some great years in there, too. So yeah, it's definitely a big honor."