Nieto's passion for the game increased after watching "The Mighty Ducks" movies, which featured players of color. He became obsessed with roller hockey and a fan of the Anaheim Ducks.
"I wouldn't miss a Ducks game," he said. "I always had my stick and skates on, re-enacting what went on during games."
Nieto began playing organized roller hockey at a local YMCA, where he first met
Emerson Etem
, who quickly became a best friend.
The two transitioned from roller hockey to ice hockey and later became part of a group of elite Southern California players drafted by NHL teams.
"We had four NHLers on my first peewee team -- myself,
Beau Bennett
, Jason Zucker and Matt," Etem said.
The Ducks chose Etem, a forward, with the No. 29 pick in the 2010 NHL Draft. He scored 46 points (22 goals, 24 assists) in 173 games with Anaheim, the New York Rangers and Vancouver Canucks before retiring in 2019. He's now the owner/coach of Long Beach of the United States Premier Hockey League.
The Pittsburgh Penguins selected Bennett, a forward, with the No. 20 pick in the 2010 draft. He scored 64 points (24 goals, 40 assists) in 200 games with the Penguins, with whom he won the Stanley Cup in 2016, New Jersey Devils and St. Louis Blues before he retired in June.
Zucker, a forward, was chosen by the Minnesota Wild in the second round (No. 59) in the 2010 draft. He has scored 273 points (147 goals, 126 assists) in 509 games with the Wild and Penguins from 2011-21.
"I credit them for a lot of my success just the way that we were able to come together, push each other," Nieto said. "We were all good friends, but when we got on the ice, we wanted to compete, and we wanted to be the best and it worked out for all of us."
Nieto also gives stick taps to his parents for making it financially possible for him to play elite level hockey. Mary Nieto worked as a makeup artist at a local Nordstrom's. Jesse was a longshoreman.
Money was so tight, Nieto's parents had him choose between playing roller and ice hockey because they couldn't afford to have him play each sport.
"I remember asking them who made more money, professional ice hockey players or professional roller hockey players?" Nieto said. "They said, 'Ice hockey players.' That's why I chose ice hockey."
At 14, Nieto headed east to study and play hockey at the Salisbury School in Salisbury, Connecticut. He played two seasons for the USA Hockey National Team Development Program and helped the U.S. win the IIHF Under-18 World Junior Championship in 2008-09 and 2009-10.
Nieto earned a scholarship to Boston University, where he scored 102 points (44 goals, 58 assists) in 115 games over three seasons. He led BU in goals (18) and was second in points (37) in 2012-13.