Soares' interest in coaching soon became talk in the women's hockey coaching grapevine. Colby coach Holley Tyng was looking for an assistant in the offseason and heard about Soares through Princeton University coach Cara Morey and Quinnipiac University coach Cassandra Turner, who each had previously been through the hiring process.
"They both were, like, 'You've got to this Oliva Soares, you've got to call her, she's fabulous,'" Tyng said. "From the first time I chatted with her, I was impressed by her maturity, her communications skills. Clearly a very good leader just by her presence. She's very relatable to my current players."
The daughter of a firefighter and a post-anesthesia care nurse, Soares grew up in Boston and played basketball until she tagged along to a friend's hockey practice.
"I saw his practice, saw his dad skating and coaching the practice," she said. "He stopped and blew the snow on the ice and I thought it was the coolest thing ever, and I had to try it."
Soares played in the Bay State Breakers youth hockey program and twice captained the girls' varsity hockey team at St. George's School in Middletown, Rhode Island. She helped it win a Division II New England Prep School championship in 2015-16 and was named team MVP that season. She went from being a star player in prep school to a role player at Ohio State, taking shifts on energy and checking lines. She scored eight points (two goals, six assists) in 142 NCAA games from 2016-20.
"As classes continued to come in with more talent, roles change, you move around and I found myself not playing as much," she said. "But in my head, I was asking, 'What can I do to still have an impact on this team? What am I going to do around the locker room? What am I going to do on the bench? What am I going to do when my number is getting called to have an impact on the program?'"