Devon Toews scored for the Avalanche (33-24-2), who were coming off a 2-1 loss to the Nashville Predators on Saturday. Mackenzie Blackwood made 22 saves.
“I liked our first 15 minutes, probably, and then it just disappeared," Colorado coach Jared Bednar said. "Both teams are in the same boat on the back-to-backs. It’s not an excuse. The three guys [Cale Makar, Nathan MacKinnon and Toews] that played in the [4 Nations] tournament, it looked like they were working as hard as they could, but they didn’t seem to have the pop that they had yesterday, which I think is understandable, which is why we kind of planned on giving them tomorrow and the next day off for those guys.
“All in all, we just didn’t have enough guys going. I don’t want to call it effort, but the competitiveness we needed to win that hockey game.”
Toews gave the Avalanche a 1-0 lead at 7:49 of the first period, tipping Makar’s wrist shot from the right point.
Makar earned his 400th NHL point on the play, making him the third-fastest defenseman in NHL history to reach the milestone (374 games). Only Bobby Orr (333) and Paul Coffey (359) did it in fewer games.
“We know as a group we have a lot better than this,” Makar said. “It’s just unfortunate when we can’t find the consistency. Obviously, played well last night but don’t find the goals. You’ve just got to get back to it and be better tonight. Unfortunately, we weren’t.”
Schenn tied it 1-1 at 10:45 of the second period after collecting Kyrou's rebound in the right circle. The goal came after Blackwood robbed the Blues captain from the slot earlier in the period.
Parayko put the Blues in front 2-1 at 14:13. He outmuscled Makar at the side of the net for a loose puck after Pavel Buchnevich threw a shot at the crease from the side boards.