Leon Draisaitl, McDavid's teammate who is second in the NHL with 75 points (27 goals, 48 assists) also was named by the players polled. In fact, some had a hard time choosing between the two Oilers forwards, as well as Boston Bruins forward David Pastrnak, who leads the NHL with 37 goals.
"The two guys in Edmonton are doing a great job," Tampa Bay Lightning defenseman Victor Hedman said. "Pastrnak is having a great season. There's so many guys. It's tough to tell."
Philadelphia Flyers forward Travis Konecny gave his vote to Eastern Conference rival Pastrnak.
"I'm sure Draisaitl and McDavid, those guys, are unbelievable, but we don't see them as much," Konecny said. "And it seems like Pastrnak scored every time you check the score sheet. So, he's incredible."
St. Louis Blues forward Ryan O'Reilly also mentioned MacKinnon, and added former Buffalo Sabres teammate Jack Eichel, who had 31 points (16 goals, 15 assists) during a 17-game point streak this season. Eichel is ninth in the NHL with 62 points (28 goals, 34 assists) in 48 games.
"The two guys that stick out in my mind are McKinnon, watching him, what he's been able to do, the numbers he's put up there is very impressive," O'Reilly said. "Also, I could say Eichel would be the equivalent of that. The point streak, when we played him, how dominant he was. I would say it would be a tie between those two guys right now."
Hedman was the only player polled to name a defenseman, John Carlson of the Washington Capitals, who is 10th in the League with 60 points (13 goals, 47 assists). Carlson leads all defensemen, with Roman Josi of the Nashville Predators second with 48 points (14 goals, 34 assists). Though Hedman named Carlson, he gave the nod to McDavid and Draisaitl.
"Even John Carlson with the season he's having so far deserves to be up there," Hedman said. "There's so many guys that obviously could win it, but I would say one of the two in Edmonton."