DeBrincat was playing at Lake Forest Academy (Illinois) in the 2013-14 season when Sherwood Bassin, general manager of Erie watched him at a game in Northern Michigan. Bassin was there to watch one of Erie's prospects, but DeBrincat caught his eye immediately.
"He gets five points, three goals, two assists, but more than that, you could see he played every position," Bassin said. "The only position he didn't play that game was goal. I'm thinking, this guy's a player."
At Erie, DeBrincat scored 332 points (167 goals, 165 assists) in 191 regular-season games and 73 points (30 goals, 43 assists) in 55 playoff games. In his final season with Erie in 2016-17, without Strome and McDavid, DeBrincat had career highs in points (127), goals (65) and assists (62).
"His heart's bigger than his body. His heart is 6-foot-5. Apparently, they got it to fit in that 5-7 body," Bassin said. "He has no fear. He's not intimidated. He can read the play so quickly, he knows where to be to get the puck, knows where to find the puck, too."
Strome, who is now DeBrincat's teammate in Chicago, played on a line with him in Erie from 2014-16 and part of the 2016-17 season. In those two full seasons together, Strome had 240 points (82 goals, 158 assists) in 124 games, and DeBrincat had 205 points (102 goals, 103 assists) in 128 games.
Strome said DeBrincat's game has evolved since then.
"He's always had the knack for scoring big goals or timely goals. His shot is underrated even still. He has a harder shot than people give him credit for, and he's really good at placing it. His overall game has improved a ton," Strome said. "He's relied on defensively on penalty kills now and sets up plays. He gave 'Kaner' an open net the other game, and maybe before he would've shot that, but he slides it over and finds the open net. He's an All-Star for a reason and he's a superstar in the NHL."
DeBrincat has one season remaining on the three-year, $19.2 million contract ($6.4 million average annual value) he signed on Oct. 3, 2019. He's off to a strong start, but could the native of Farmington Hills, Michigan, end up being one of the NHL's best goal-scorers?
Don't discount the possibility, Knoblauch said.
"That's Alex's story, he enjoys people doubting him," Knoblach said. "He's confident in his abilities, and there's no way he could have that success if he wasn't confident."
NHL.com independent correspondent Bruce Miles contributed to this report