The Hurricanes players went into the winning dressing room laughing, cheering loudly and chanting "Dave! Dave! Dave!" Ayres was the last to leave the ice but was stopped halfway up the tunnel.
"They told me I had to go back out there because I was the first star," he said. "I'll take it."
When he did get to the dressing room, he was doused by sprays of water by his new teammates.
"I wish it had been champagne but we didn't have any," Staal said. "What an unreal story."
Down the hallway in the Toronto dressing room, coach Sheldon Keefe was unhappy with the loss but said he felt good for Ayres. Keefe was Marlies coach from 2015 until he replaced Mike Babcock on the Maple Leafs on Nov. 20 and, as such, is very familiar with Ayres.
"He's got great energy, he comes to the rink every day, wants to work and wants to be a part of it," Keefe said. "Whether it's with the Marlies or Leafs, he's always there when you need him. There probably isn't an emergency goalie anywhere in pro hockey who has seen as many pro shots as this guy. He's in every day getting work.
"It feels terrible that at the end of the night, he's on the other side from our end of it, but on a personal note, you can't help but feel pretty darn good for the guy."
The Hurricanes tweeted that they are working with Ayres to make a donation to a kidney foundation, just another special touch on such a special night, which included a tweet from North Carolina governor Roy Cooper that he would make Ayres an honorary member of the state.
"It's pretty special," Carolina coach Rod Brind'Amour said. "You know, I told the guys after the game to thank him because that just gave me an incredible memory. ... What a moment for him that he can have the rest of his life. That's incredible.
"That's why you do this."
Ayres made eight saves on 10 shots, was credited with a shot on goal, and got the win. He was seen leaving the arena carrying a case of beer and his equipment inside a Toronto Marlies bag, and had his Hurricanes No. 90 jersey, which he said he'll hang somewhere at home.
"I'm going to look at it every day," he said.
Not bad for a guy who once thought he'd never play hockey again.