Penguin Random House Canada found a recording booth at Gwynne Sound in downtown Cincinnati, where the 31-year-old Detroit native holed up for four days with a sound producer on site and a director in Canada patched in via Zoom.
"I had to record the book on a Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday," Fitzhugh said. "Our moving truck came the following Thursday, like three days later. In between packing up our apartment and trying to get all the boxes filled and run all the errands, I was otherwise engaged for about six hours for those final seven days that we probably needed to get our stuff packed. Obviously, it all got done and we got here just in time and in good spirits."
Fitzhugh had more audio work to do when he arrived in Seattle. "I had to do a half hour here, do some pick-ups, a couple of edits, some unclear lines, things I had to re-read," he said.
He said doing the audiobook was a fun challenge that was different from reading "'Of Mice and Men' aloud back in the ninth grade" or doing a hockey broadcast.
"Because his story is so multilayered -- you go from the joy of growing up in Fredericton, discovering hockey and playing all these sports to experiencing racism for the first time, the heartbreak of the injury, the NHL dream deferred multiple times and then the pinnacle of finally getting there," he said. "There are a lot of different stories in his overall story, so trying to find a voice for each one of those layers, I think, was the most challenging part. It's not like a broadcast where you have the same energy all throughout the game. You're reading and you're trying to convey certain messages, trying to convey certain viewpoints."
Garrison said Fitzhugh succeeded on all fronts.
"You know how warm [Fitzhugh's] voice is, how gentle and thoughtful he sounds. Willie is like that too," Garrison said. "Willie has very little swagger, very little of the sense that he's full of himself. Willie is just there to make things better, and that's exactly the kind of person Everett is and that's what he sounds like. It was a perfect fit, couldn't have been better."
Fitzhugh said he enjoyed the experience so much that he would love to do it again.
"Maybe I did find a nice little side hustle reading audiobooks," he said. "You never know."