Karlsson tied it 2-2 at 6:34 on a wrist shot off a face-off win. It was his 10th goal in 13 games this season after scoring 10 in 50 games in 2021-22.
"I think we slowed our game down," Reinhart said. "A little bit too much standing around watching, and they swarmed us."
Benning gave the Sharks a 3-2 lead at 11:48 with a shot from the blue line after Karlsson set him up with a between-the-legs pass.
"I think we've made strides, and we're scoring more goals, for sure," Quinn said. "We're playing better hockey, obviously. We've got to cut down on the goals we're giving up, but I do like the fact that we are scoring more goals."
NOTES:Meier has four goals in his past four games. … Karlsson has 12 points (seven goals, five assists) in a four-game point streak. … Benning goal was his first with San Jose since signing a four-year contract July 13.