Gilmour understands how fixed the cumulative public eye is on the Maple Leafs. Still one of the most popular Maple Leafs of all time, the 55-year-old holds Toronto's single-season record for points with 127 (32 goals, 95 assists) in 1992-93.
"People in Toronto are crazy about hockey," said Gilmour, who played for the Maple Leafs from 1992-97. "I remember one time, in order not to get mobbed while going to a game at Maple Leaf Gardens when I was a Leaf, I dressed up like myself. I put on a Doug Gilmour No. 93 Leafs jersey, a Leafs ball cap, sunglasses, and walked into the rink like just another fan. No one thought it was actually me.
"That's the fanfare, the scrutiny that there is for a Leaf in Toronto. There's something about them on TV pretty much every day. And that can be tough on young players. But there is no better place to play. They'll learn that. And John can help them with that.
"John is from the Toronto area and was in the spotlight at a young age dating back to junior. He knows what he's getting into. He came here for a reason."
Gilmour recalled how Tavares petitioned to gain eligibility to play major junior in the Ontario Hockey League in the spring of 2005. OHL rules did not allow players under the age of 15 to be drafted, so the league introduced an exceptional player clause, allowing the 14-year-old Tavares to be drafted one year sooner than he would otherwise have been eligible.