Some may be on the NHL Network's list (none of the writers were privy to the list when they voted), but others may not.
To be eligible, a goalie must have played in fewer than 150 NHL games. Other than that, it was fair game to pick experienced goalies on the verge of becoming established No. 1s or prospects who could rise rapidly through the ranks.
Our writers delivered with an eclectic mix of goalies.
Connor Hellebuyck of the Winnipeg Jets and Matt Murray of the Pittsburgh Penguins dominated the votes, as expected; each is already an established No. 1 on an elite team. But after that, the voting was spread out. Antti Raanta of the Arizona Coyotes was a strong candidate, and some liked the thought of Carter Hutton getting a chance to be No. 1 with the Buffalo Sabres. Philipp Grubauer, another backup moving to a new team in the Colorado Avalanche, earned votes as well. Juuse Saros, the starter-in-waiting behind Pekka Rinne with the Nashville Predators, was a popular pick. Even
Carter Hart
, the uber-prospect with the Philadelphia Flyers, got a mention.
Our writers reveal some of their picks and explain the rationale behind them.
Connor Hellebuyck, Winnipeg Jets -- No disrespect to any of the other goaltenders mentioned, but this was a relatively easy choice for me. Hellebuyck emerged as one of the best goalies in the NHL last season and was a finalist for the Vezina Trophy. He's just entering the prime of his career -- he turned 25 on May 19 -- and he only got better with an increased workload; his goals-against average (2.36) and save percentage (.924, .922) in the regular season and Stanley Cup Playoffs were nearly identical. With a solid group in front of him, expect Hellebuyck to build on what was a stellar season. -- Brian Compton, deputy managing editor