As Reimer skated onto the ice in Toronto for Game 2, the memories of his historic night came flooding back to Ayres.
"It reminded me of when I skated out in that game after their goalies, Reimer and Petr Mrazek, got hurt," Ayres said. "Same rink. Same entrance. Same bench. And they're wearing the same white Canes jerseys they wore that night."
Making the matchup a bit difficult for him was that the Hurricanes were playing the Bruins, the team he grew up rooting for. His favorite player was goalie Andy Moog, who won 136 games with Boston from 1987-93.
"I loved watching him play," he said. "But obviously I'm pulling for the Hurricanes."
The next three hours proved to be a roller coaster of emotions.
It was a 2-2 game when Hurricanes defenseman Dougie Hamilton scored at 8:30 of the third period. Ayres said his nerves were put to the test in the final seconds when Reimer was channeling his inner Dominik Hasek, flopping in his crease and doing snow angels while the Bruins were buzzing around the Carolina net in an unsuccessful attempt to tie the score.
"That's not really Reimer's style, but he did whatever he had to to keep the puck out," Ayres said. "As a goalie I can appreciate that.
"What a great win."
Ayres said he's in frequent contact with Mike Sundheim and Pace Sagester of the Hurricanes public relations department. He also exchanges texts with team analyst Tripp Tracy.
"I like to keep track and get the inside word of what's going on with the guys," he said.
Given his relationship with the team, the city of Raleigh and the state of North Carolina, it's easy to see why.
On Feb. 25, Gov. Roy Cooper declared Ayres, a Canadian citizen, an honorary citizen of North Carolina. The city of Raleigh declared Feb. 25 "David Ayres Day."
Ayres, who became the oldest goalie (42 years, 194 days) to win his NHL regular-season debut, became an overnight sensation after helping the Hurricanes defeat Toronto. There were TV appearances on "Today" and "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert," and countless interviews with various media outlets.
Ayres hasn't forgotten how he was embraced. Because of that, he said he hopes to return to Carolina later this year.
"I'm cheering for the Canes to win the Stanley Cup," he said. "And if they do, you can bet I'm heading down there for the parade.
"Go Canes!"