His moment came Saturday. After Hurricanes starter James Reimer left with a lower-body injury at 6:10 of the first period, he had to go downstairs just in case. After Hurricanes backup Petr Mrazek left with a head injury with 8:41 left in the second, he had to put a Carolina jersey over his Toronto gear and play.
Sarah was still in Section 317.
"It was like an eternity watching guys just standing on the ice," she said. "Mrazek had already gone off, and I'm thinking, 'OK, what's going on? Like, is Reimer coming back, or what's happening?' It felt like forever for him to get on the ice, and then he stepped on. I actually grabbed the guy who I didn't know beside me and screamed, 'That's my husband!' "
This is where the story starts to get good. Ayres gave up two goals on two shots. The fans cheered, because the Maple Leafs cut the Hurricanes' lead from 4-1 to 4-3, but they also apologized to Sarah.
"They were like, 'Sorry. Sorry,' " she said. "I'm like, 'No, it's OK. He'll be fine.' "
He was, thanks in part to his new teammates.
"I just kind of looked up at the scoreboard, and I just said to myself, 'You need to make a save here. You can't go out and embarrass yourself like this,' " he said. "And then a couple of players come to me and they say, 'Don't worry about it. Let in 10 goals. We don't care. Just go out there and have a lot of fun with it.' "
Sarah received three beers from fans but drank about a half of one because she didn't want to miss anything while in the restroom. An usher invited her to move down and sit in an empty seat.
The Hurricanes shut down the Maple Leafs, and Ayres shut them out in the third period, making one particularly memorable save on center Auston Matthews, who is second in the NHL with 43 goals. Two days earlier, Ayres and Matthews had done a video shoot together.
"He had to shoot low blocker," Ayres said. "The first three shots, I stopped all three. He said, 'Come on, Dave. Like, let one in. I've got to score for the commercial.' So when he came down, I knew he was going to short-side blocker on me."
Ayres was selected as the game's first star. Even though the Maple Leafs lost, fans stayed to give the opposing goalie a standing ovation. Sarah was on the phone with her mother.
"I was screaming," she said. "I just know I was probably the loudest one in that building."