Van Riemsdyk plays at Navesink annually at Christmastime, save for last year because of the pandemic, playing in a shinny game with family, including brother Trevor, a Washington Capitals defenseman, friends and former high school and club teammates on the outdoor rink at Navesink Country Club.
The tradition started nine years ago. Van Riemsdyk hopes it will resume this Christmas.
"Spending my summers in Minnesota, I don't get a ton of chances to go home and see my buddies," he said. "That's one of the best things about it, getting to see a bunch of friends I don't see too often and remember the glory days of when we played growing up. All those years go by, but when I get back out there on the ice with those guys it takes me right back to being a youth hockey player and how much fun we had with it."
James' father, Frans, came up with the idea for the game and ran it past Mike Reynolds, the hockey director at Navesink Country Club who also coached James and Trevor when they were in high school at Christian Brothers Academy in Lincroft.
"The next thing you know we got it going, and we had kids come up too and did a clinic for them," Reynolds said. "James stayed on with Trevor and their other brother, Brendan. Then we played the game."
Reynolds said he's always busting chops, telling guys they're late, getting on them for not backchecking, giving them the old coach spiel.
"James says it's more for Frans than anybody," Reynolds said with a laugh. "Frans will come to the rink a couple days early and try to get back in shape. He'll skate with me, do drills, try to get ready for the big game. They kind of make fun of him, their father, but he gets all gung-ho for the game. James always tries to get him a goal or two. It's great. It's fun watching them all."
The scene at the van Riemsdyk house when they are getting ready for the game finds Frans, James, Trevor and Brendan scrounging for gear, trading pieces to find the right ones, leaving on mismatched equipment if need be, and making a mess.