They met while playing in a tournament with the New York City Gay Hockey Association in 2008. It was Knoerzer's first tournament.
"That's when I met Mike, at the banquet for the tournament," Knoerzer said. "I didn't really know anybody at all. I was standing by myself, put on a Pittsburgh Penguins hat and then here he comes, introducing himself and asking if I like the Penguins. And I think that's pretty much what started the story that we now know today."
Knoerzer and Marsico combined their love for each other, the Penguins and hockey to form the Pittsburgh Tigers, a team that provides a fun, competitive space for LGBTQ+ players to play without fear of being hassled or judged because of their sexuality.
"When we got the group together it really became an outlet for people who grew up playing hockey, either here in Pittsburgh, which is a big hockey town since Mario (Lemieux) came here, or in other cities and they ended up moving here," said Marsico, a Pittsburgh native. "They've given up the sports for various reasons, very often because they felt like they didn't have a place to play, very often because they were made fun of for being gay or they didn't want people to know."
The Tigers are another branch from the NYCGHA tree, similar to the Madison (Wisconsin) Gay Hockey Association, the nation's largest gay hockey league, which was founded by former NYCGHA player Patrick Farabaugh in 2006.
"I would say New York, Toronto and Montreal were really the seed for everybody else," Marsico said. "I think one of the draws for our league is the opportunity is to play with other cities, and New York, Toronto and Montreal have done a very great job of showing us the way."
The Tigers are a small group, including a core of about 15 players and another of 10-15 who drop in for games that were held weekly before Pittsburgh rinks closed in March due to concerns surrounding the coronavirus.
"We're not as big as New York, we're not as big as Toronto in terms of a hockey league, but the folks that we do have, they're here because they love the game, they love being together and we inspire others," Marsico said. "We've had other people join our team because they see us playing and see us enjoy it so much that they come up to us after the game and want to be a part of it."