The record, though, was secondary to the disappointing finish for the Rangers. They led 1-0 in the first period, 2-1 in the second and 3-2 in the third but couldn't hold any of the leads.
"We've had a tendency at times when we're winning 2-1 to act like it's 5-1," Rangers coach David Quinn said. "Such a fine line between winning and losing at this level, and you've got to finish the job."
Lundqvist was particularly disappointed by how he was beaten on the overtime winner; he said the shot went through the five-hole even though it didn't appear to him that Toffoli was shooting for that.
"It hurts, definitely," Lundqvist said. "I thought we played really well the whole game, but that overtime goal sums it up, not only this game but a lot of games. The effort is there, crossbar and out, misses the shot and I don't know what to think. It's just really frustrating."