Matthews had a goal and an assist and Anthony Stolarz made 25 saves for the Maple Leafs (8-13-3), who are 0-7-1 in their past eight. William Nylander had two assists.
The Kings trailed 3-0 early in the second period before scoring three straight goals in just under 12 minutes to tie the game.
“At 3-0 we just took our foot off the gas a little bit, that’s what I’d say,” Toronto coach Jim Hiller said. “We wanted to keep going, we certainly didn’t dominate the game but I thought we had our legs and it was back and forth and then when we got up three, I don’t know, we just didn’t have as much energy or play with as much urgency.”
Joel Armia’s point shot deflected off Turcotte at the top of the goal crease to cut it to 3-1 at 2:55 of the second period, 21 seconds after Toronto stretched the lead to three.
“It’s just been too many times where we’ve scored and the next shift they’ve scored,” Hiller said. “That’s probably on me, I’ve got to find a better combination of players, it’s happened too many times… I’ve never seen anything like it.”
Defenseman Mikey Anderson said getting a goal so quickly after Toronto pushed the lead to three was crucial in the comeback.
“Huge…,” Anderson said. “Just getting a shift in the offensive zone, Turcotte finding his way to the net, hits his butt or whatever it’s a ‘Turc’ goal. It’s a big moment, big for that line and those are the shifts that can build momentum. Especially on the road, we needed it.”
Laferriere brought the Kings to within one goal when he deflected Kempe’s shot on the power play at the top of the goal crease to make it 3-2 at 10:11.
Haula tied it 3-3 at 14:51. Anderson’s shot was blocked by Troy Stecher but the rebound came to Haula in the slot, who shot over Stolarz’s glove.
“In the second period, I felt we were getting through the neutral zone pretty fast,” Haula said. “We were able to get in on the forecheck, hem them in for long shifts and try to outwork them to get some solid looks at the net.”
Kuemper kept it 3-3 in overtime with a reaching stick save on Matthews at 2:23 and a save on Darren Raddysh’s breakaway at 2:54.
“Guys stuck with it, found a way to get a few and Darcy stole the show again for us which was good,” Anderson said. “It was a good gritty one for us to get.”
Matthews put Toronto up 1-0 at 13:54 of the first period on the power play when he took a cross-slot pass from Nylander and shot over Kuemper’s glove from below the right face-off dot. The assist ended a five-game pointless streak for Nylander.