So when coach Rod Brind'Amour looked down the bench for someone to replace Drury on the Hurricanes' top line with Sebastian Aho and Seth Jarvis, the decision was actually pretty simple.
"I just didn't have really much choice," Brind'Amour said. "Sometimes it's easy. The choices are made for you and when you're short, you're looking at the next guy up."
That next guy was Mackenzie MacEachern, who turned out to be the perfect fit with Aho and Jarvis, finishing with a goal and an assist in Carolina's 5-2 win at UBS Arena.
There were plenty of other heroes for Carolina, which earned its first road win in the Stanley Cup Playoffs since 2021 (1-8) and took a 3-1 lead in the best-of-7 series. Jarvis scored two goals, Aho had a goal and two assists, and Antti Raanta made 27 saves.
But MacEachern's performance in his first NHL game this season provided an example of what the Hurricanes will need to not only advance beyond the Islanders, but also make the run at the Stanley Cup they expected when this season began.
"It's kind of been our situation for a while now," Aho said. "We talked about it. It's going to definitely be a team effort. It can't be one guy. It's just every player just gives that one extra inch and that's how you move forward."
RELATED: [Complete Hurricanes vs. Islanders series coverage]
The Hurricanes can move past the Islanders with another win at home in Game 5 on Tuesday (7 p.m. ET; ESPN, SNE, SNO, SNP, TVAS, BSSO, MSG, MSGSN). Then, they'd faced the winner of the Eastern Conference First Round series between the New York Rangers and New Jersey Devils.
But if they get that far, they might not have anyone return to help out their depleted forward corps. Brind'Amour didn't have an update postgame on Drury, who was injured on a hit from New York defenseman Ryan Pulock, which resulted in a boarding penalty.
Drury was Carolina's previous "next man up," filling in for Teuvo Teravainen, who is out indefinitely after breaking his left hand in Game 2 on Wednesday. With Andrei Svechnikov (torn ACL) and Max Pacioretty (torn Achilles) out for the season, the Hurricanes are missing three of their top six forwards.
That means they'll need more from top players such as Aho and Jarvis, but also unlikely heroes like MacEachern, who thought he was going to be one of Carolina's "Black Aces" when he was called up from Chicago of the American Hockey League on Thursday. The 29-year-old got a heads up on Saturday that he might play, and it was confirmed when he saw his name on the lineup sheet when arrived at UBS Arena on Sunday.
"You never want to see somebody get hurt, but it kind of gave me an opportunity to play with two unbelievable players and I tried to run with it," MacEachern said.
MacEachern's only previous NHL playoff experience came with the St. Louis Blues in the Edmonton bubble in 2020. After signing a one-year contract with Carolina last summer, he missed the first three months of this season with injuries before returning and finishing with 30 points (11 goals, 19 assists) in 37 AHL games with Chicago.