It wasn't easy. At times in this series the Lightning forecheck was dominant and resulted in significant offensive zone time for Tampa Bay. And when they thumped the Maple Leafs 7-3 in Game 1 at Air Canada Centre, the narrative in Toronto became "Here we go again."
But this time it was different. Keefe said it throughout the series about the vibe, the composure, the feel of his team.
In the end, the difference was that this edition answered the challenge. And whenever a big moment came, they rose to the occasion, unlike so many previous times.
That was never more underscored than how they played in Tampa. The Maple Leafs won all three games at Amalie Arena, each one in overtime. In past seasons, that never happened, whether it be because of a lull, because of a mistake, or because of a bad bounce.
This time, the bounce went their way.
In the victorious dressing room, there were screams of joy. Co-owner Larry Tanenbaum couldn't wipe the smile off his face. Wayne Simmonds, the imposing 6-foot-2, 184 pound forward who'd been a healthy scratch, came prancing down the hallway screaming and hollering. They'd all waited so long for this moment. And now it was here.
There were so many heroes for the Maple Leafs in this series. Tavares, of course. There was Matthews, who opened the scoring at 13:47 of the second period and led Toronto in goals in the series with five. There was Rielly, the longest-tenured player on the team (2013) who had eight points (three goals, five assists). And don't forget goalie Ilya Samsonov, who made 31 saves and could hardly formulate answers to reporters afterward because of his exhaustion.
And then there was Marner, who led the team in scoring in the series with 11 points (two goals, nine assists). Like Tavares, the 25-year-old who grew up in the Toronto area as an avid Maple Leafs fan who gobbled up every morsel of information about the team he could find, including the history. In fact, he wore No. 93 with London of the Ontario Hockey League in honor of Toronto icon Doug Gilmour, who played his final game with the Maple Leafs in 1997, a year before Marner was born.
On a night of special moments, the big picture was not lost on the Toronto forward.
"Crazy, man," Marner said. "I had a pretty good sight of [the goal] the whole time. The whole celebration, I was kind of in front of Johnny, both kids that grew up in the area and wanted to do something special for this team.
"A special moment."
For a team. For a fanbase. And for a city that had waited almost two decades for it.