Tavares said talk of becoming captain was not part of his contract negotiations, and Matthews multiple times this offseason said he would be OK with whatever decision is made by management, including coach Mike Babcock.
"In the end, Kyle, [Mike], everybody, they're preaching patience," Matthews said July 26. "In the end, they'll figure something out, but it's not something I focus on. I just focus on getting better."
Phaneuf had been Maple Leafs captain since the 2010-11 season. Last season, defenseman Morgan Rielly and forwards Tyler Bozak and Leo Komarov were alternate captains. Bozak (St. Louis Blues) and Komarov (Islanders) left this offseason as free agents.
"We hope that all of our young players, whether that's Morgan, William [Nylander], Jake Gardiner, Auston and Mitch [Marner] can continue to evolve as leaders as well," Dubas said. "I don't put a huge amount of emphasis on it. I've always thought that in studying teams, they were always best when they are patient with naming their captain and not rushing to name somebody then having to make a move later to take it away and all the drama that can come with that."
The Maple Leafs begin training camp Sept. 13 and open the regular season Oct. 3 against the Montreal Canadiens.
"It is a very important decision and not one that I think can be rushed whatsoever," Dubas said.