Scheifele said he's been reluctant to talk much about his faith but has recently been more open about it.
"I've always been the kind of guy that, well, people would rather see a Christian than hear a Christian, so that's always been my motto, that I want to be someone to be like, that you know there's something different about him, that he shines a different light than most and I don't have to go out and preach to anyone or hit people over the head with a Bible," he said. "I want my actions to show I'm a Christian, a person of faith. I'm definitely happy to share my story and my journey with God. It's a pretty big part of my life but I definitely am not going to hit you on the head with a Bible to try to show you who I am."
Scheifele's will to win doesn't have an off switch, even outside of hockey.
Last summer, he and his friend Ben Fanelli went to play pickleball one day and during the friendly match, as a lark, they propped up a phone camera to record some of the action. Later, over dinner, Scheifele pulled out the phone, cued up the video and started studying and analyzing it.
Fanelli was amused and amazed, but hardly surprised.
"He was trying to figure out how he could get better at pickleball," Fanelli said. "He takes it to the next level, that he makes everything a competition. He will do everything he can to win.
"He just grew up that way."
Scheifele's intense desire to win is fueled even more in the Stanley Cup Playoffs. Last season, Scheifele set a postseason record by scoring 11 goals on the road, helping the Jets reach the Western Conference Final, where they lost in five games to the Vegas Golden Knights.
"Obviously it's a cool thing but the way I look at it is that it didn't really get us anywhere," said Scheifele, who had 14 playoff goals last season, second-most in the League behind the 15 scored by Alex Ovechkin of the Cup-winning Washington Capitals. "We got to the conference final but it doesn't really matter unless you win the Stanley Cup. Obviously, you gain that experience from it but at the end of the day, you're not here to get NHL records, you're here to win Stanley Cups."
Winnipeg finished second in the Central Division this season and lost the first two games of the series to the Blues, 2-1 in Game 1 and 4-3 in Game 2.
Now, the Jets look, in part, to Scheifele to help pull them out of the playoff hole they are in.
"He wants to be the best at everything," Fanelli said. "For him, it's an almost innate need to be in control or dominating in a certain way. In his mind, it's almost like that is the norm, to be successful and the best. And he focuses on that, and not just hockey, so then everything else falls into place."